Callum Borchers' Blog

Sociologically significant sports (and class assignments)

Posts Tagged ‘wellesley

Right to know vs. right to privacy

leave a comment »

This is off my beat, but I believe it’s worth sharing.

Last Wednesday, I wrote an article for Wellesley Patch, called “Wellesley Police Make First Arrests of Thanksgiving Week.” The story included brief accounts of two drunk driving arrests that occurred in the days leading up to the holiday. In keeping with the publication’s standard practice, we posted the offenders’ names and addresses.

On Monday, I received the following e-mail:

Hi Callum, I appreciate your attempting to alert the community, and as a mother of 4 children, I greatly appreciate what you are doing, but there is another side to this story that you should have been aware before you wrote this. A drunk driving offense could happen to anybody, you included. Pam Stanley is a loving, single mother who was on her way home from a holiday party. True her eyes were blood shot, but a big reason is because she had been crying. I understand that you want to report a story, but it is NOT necessary, and frankly I find irresponsible reporting, to print her full name and address. Because of your article, she is now in a position that she could lose her job. Then she would not be able to find another job once anyone hears the circumstances in which she were fired. She is the sole provider of her family. Her husband barely contributes in any way. He is living in VT and barely sees the children. Do you want this on your shoulders? I see that you are young. Since you had no problem including her name, seems to me that you haven’t yet made any mistakes in your life that you regret. Callum, one day you will and, for your sake, I hope no one throws it in your face the way you did to Ms. Stanley. This is Ms. Stanley’s first and last time offense. As wrong as what she did, she should be entitled to make a mistake and to her privacy as a first time offender. I am asking that you please delete her name and address from your article immediately – and certainly before her employment sees this. Thank you. Lauri

Today, I responded:

Hi Lauri,

Thank you for taking time to write to me. Ms. Stanley is lucky to have a friend like you who stands up for her.

I certainly can appreciate your perspective. An arrest report documents a single event, often a person’s most shameful event. It does not include all the good things a person has done in the past, nor does it account for other challenges in a person’s life. I understand why that seems unfair. Sometimes, a good person makes a bad decision.

However, the standard practice of Wellesley Patch and many other publications is to publish the names and addresses of all arrested individuals. Such information is publicly available at any police station in this country. Understand that while Ms. Stanley might desire privacy, she is not entitled to it. In fact, it is the public that is entitled to know the identities of people arrested in their communities.

I hope you are right that this was the first and last time Ms. Stanley will be arrested for OUI and that people who know her will — like you — not forget all of her admirable qualities because of an isolated incident.

Have a safe and happy holiday season,

Callum

Just an interesting reminder that we cover real people with real consequences. It’s easy to get frustrated when people don’t understand or appreciate what we do, but I think it’s important for us to understand their perspectives, too.

Advertisements

Written by callumborchers

November 30, 2010 at 3:43 pm

Slideshow: Antiques show a stage for the expensive, eccentric

leave a comment »

Sandie Fowler of Antique Articles in Dunstable surveys her collection of late 19th and early 20th century tiles. Fowler and her business partner, Wendy Harvey, were among scores of vendors showing off their collectibles at the 3rd Annual Antiques at Elm Bank. Click photo to view slideshhow.

The clock is a paradox: enormous, standing at least eight feet tall, yet delicate, its deep wood adorned by hand-painted filigrees and flowers; European in its structure, yet Asian in much of its design. It is labeled, rather modestly, an “early English tall clock,” made by William Kipling in London around 1740, and housed by an ornate Japanese case. At $12,500, it was one of the finest — and most expensive — items displayed at the third annual Antiques at Elm Bank Estate show in Wellesley.

The two-day event featured 85 antiques vendors, whose wares ranged from jewelry to furniture, silverware to timeless timepieces, like the tall clock shown by Hills Antique Clock Shop of Holliston.

“We restored this one to how it would have looked in 1740,” said Richard Hills, the shop’s owner. “And that one at the back,” he added, indicating a large wall clock, beautiful on its own merit but austere compared to the Kipling, “we believe came from a railway station in Newton Highlands.”

The oak-framed Seth Thomas piece, made between 1879 and 1896, bears the label “NEWTON HIGHLANDS 1904,” painted gold on the glass covering the clock’s pendulum

Hills confessed the show was his first ever, revealing a newcomer status that put him in the minority among tentfulls of seasoned sellers.

There were Kim Kassner and Jim McElroy of Orleans, owners of The Brewster Shop Antiques. The retired couple smiled as they admitted their business’ name is slightly misleading — there is, in fact, no shop. They simply set up shop at shows like this one all over the region.

“This is what we do,” McElroy said, standing beside a 19th century cabinet that came from West End Dairies in Bridport, England and still advertises eggs at 3 pence per dozen. “We keep all the stuff in our house and probably come to three or four shows a month.”

Sandie Fowler and Wendy Harvey, owners of Antique Articles in Dunstable, are similarly well-traveled, attending 20 to 30 shows per year, by their estimation. The women specialize in late 19th and early 20th century tiles, mostly 6-by-6-inch squares of art that one would be ashamed to lay on a floor.

Their prized piece is much larger, however: a roughly 12-by-18-inch tile depicting two robed children, one holding a badminton racket, the other playing some sort of woodwind instrument. The panel, surrounded by a gilded frame, was designed by W.S. Coleman and made by Minton China Works around 1880.

“It’s an extraordinary piece,” Fowler said. “The size alone makes it rare. We’re not sure if the frame is original, but that’s how it would have been displayed — hung on a wall.”

It would take $3,800 for Fowler and Harvey to part with it.

While some vendors clearly take special pride in particular items, Harold Tither III, co-owner of Harold Tither III & Robert Sears in Somers, Conn., looked like a father told to name his favorite child when asked to identify the most significant piece among his extensive collection of 19th and 20th century silverware.

“All of them,” Tither said, unable to fulfill the request.

There seemed to be more browsing than buying at Elm Bank (aren’t antiques for looking, anyway?) but Stephen Tassone of Newton was one patron willing to open his checkbook for a couple good finds, even if they only fit the open-ended category of “pretty things.”

“It doesn’t have to be anything incredibly rare or valuable,” Tassone said, holding a blue-and-white pot, while his wife paid for a pitcher. “We just enjoy coming to these shows. We go to a few different ones. It’s fun.”

Written by callumborchers

October 3, 2010 at 5:05 pm